Bronisław Huberman: From child prodigy to resistance fighter against National Socialism

Bronisław Huberman, ca. 1928. Unknown photographer, Library of Congress, George Grantham Bain Collection, Washington, DC
Bronisław Huberman, ca. 1928. Unknown photographer, Library of Congress, George Grantham Bain Collection, Washington, DC

The final line-up, however, was in a constant state of flux because Huberman filled the various orchestra positions with different people depending on future conductors, and some of the musicians returned to Europe because of the climate and the problematic living conditions in Palestine or moved on to other continents, such as North and South America. Sometimes the musicians’ life plans changed altogether.[49] Huberman himself gave up his residence in Vienna in the late summer of 1936, presumably because of the political developments there and the anti-Semitism which was becoming ever more threatening. He initially went to Italy before settling in Switzerland in 1938. The start of the concert season in Palestine, which was planned for autumn 1936, was delayed because of the Arab revolt. The last musicians and their families did not arrive in Palestine, individually and in groups, until November. Steinberg, who had consulted with Toscanini in Italy about the work, took over the rehearsals. Toscanini, who the orchestra musicians considered the most feared conductor of his time, arrived in Tel Aviv on 20 December 1936 after travelling by rail and plane from Milan via Brindisi, Athens and Alexandria. On the whole, he was happy with the rehearsals, but criticised the typical “German” way of playing: “Don’t play me any Prussian marches. […] Play with a light touch, like the French or the Italians”, he demanded of the orchestra (Fig. 10).[50]

The inaugural concert on 26 December 1936 was filled to the rafters with more than two thousand five hundred people in the audience. The programme included an overture by Rossini, the second symphony by Brahms, Schubert’s “Unfinished”, Nocturne and Scherzo from Mendelssohn’s “Summer Night’s Dream”, and the “Oberon” overture by Carl Maria von Weber. The concert was repeated several times in Tel Aviv, Haifa and Jerusalem and was transmitted by Jerusalem radio via Cairo and London to the US. By 5 January, fifteen thousand visitors had experienced the ten concerts, shows for workers, and public rehearsals. From 7 to 12 January 1937, Toscanini and the orchestra went on tour to Cairo and Alexandria. Huberman deliberately did not take part in these concerts so that the orchestra could take centre stage.[51]

 

[49] Compare in this portal (https://www.porta-polonica.de/de/lexikon/broches-raphael) the biography of the Polish-Jewish violinist Raphael Broches (1906-1941?) who came to Palestine in December 1936 from Hamburg to take up his place in the orchestra but returned to Germany in the January to finish his musicological doctorate. Broches was presumably deported from the Warsaw Ghetto to the Treblinka concentration camp in 1941 and murdered there.

[50] Memories of Heinrich Schiefler, in: 40 Years. The Israel Philharmonic Orchestra, Tel Aviv 1976

[51] For the Toscanini concerts and the first concert season, compare von der Lühe 1993 (see Literature), page 1046, and von der Lühe 1998 (see Literature), page 156-160

Media library
  • Fig. 1: The child prodigy, 1889

    Bronisław Huberman as a seven-year-old, 1889
  • Fig. 2: As a youth, ca. 1895

    Bronisław Huberman at a young age, ca. 1895 Unknown photographer, albumin print, 14.7 x 10.1 cm, Nationalmuseum Warsaw/Muzeum Narodowe w Warszawie, Inv. No. DI 103634 MNW
  • Fig. 3: As a fourteen-year-old, 1896

    Bronisław Huberman as a fourteen-year-old, 1896 Photograph by R. Wilhelm, New York, Philip Hale Photograph Collection, Boston Public Library
  • Fig. 4: Bronislaw Huberman, 1900

    Bronisław Huberman as an eighteen-year-old, 1900
  • Fig. 5: Emil Orlik: Huberman, ca. 1915

    Emil Orlik: Portrait of Bronisław Huberman with violin, ca. 1915 Etching, 24.5 x 29.3 cm
  • Fig. 6: Lesser Ury: Huberman, ca. 1916

    Lesser Ury: Portrait of Bronisław Huberman, ca. 1916 pastel on board, 97.2 x 70.7 cm, Jewish Museum Berlin, Inv. No. GHZ 78/1/0
  • Fig. 7: “Vaterland Europa”, 1932

    Bronislaw Huberman: Vaterland Europa, Berlin 1932
  • Fig. 8: Open letter to Furtwängler, 1933

    Open letter from Bronisław Huberman to Wilhelm Furtwängler, Prager Tagblatt from 13 September 1933, Austrian National Library
  • Fig. 9: Einstein meets Huberman, 1936

    The physicist Albert Einstein meets Bronisław Huberman 1936 in his house in Princeton, New Jersey
  • Fig. 10: Toscanini rehearses with the Palestine Orchestra, 1936

    The Palestine Orchestra during a rehearsal under the leadership of Arturo Toscanini, presumably in December 1936